Showing posts with label the Rational Society. Show all posts
Showing posts with label the Rational Society. Show all posts

11 October 2013

Technocracy

In a convoluted turn of events which began with the politics of Germany (specifically the Christian Democratic Union) with a major stop at political color, I ended up reading about the technocracy movement. Now I've been interested in the idea of technocracy for a long time, particularly because I advocated a similar program long before I ever read the word. By the time I encountered the idea, though, I'd largely abandoned that program in favor of liberal capitalism.

After my first dip into the technocratic pond, I considered the idea of combining the better aspects of technocracy with capitalism, which I termed capital technocracy. Though I didn't get very far along articulating my ideas at the time, I'd now describe the idea of capital technocracy as using the opposing forces of self-interest and competition exemplified in capitalism to achieve technocratic ends. In English, that means that forward-thinking entrepreneurs end up making the best decisions in their pursuit of profit, leading to optimal outcomes. At that time, my understanding of capitalism was primarily based on competition, rather than understanding markets as a whole.

I re-approached the idea of technocracy from a market capitalist perspective, and realized that the idea of integrating capitalism and technocracy is still essentially valid, but requires a different tack. Markets are essential giant organizers, which aggregate the value decisions of millions of actors to result in a price. The technocrats rejected the price system because of the bust in 1929, but I think that central banking deserves more blame than prices (?!) for starting the Great Depression. The technocrats thought that central planners could make economic decisions better than millions of people could for themselves, and that is the fatal conceit, isn't it? In 1935 I can understand that position; having seen the abject failure of the Soviet Union compared to market economies, I can not.

Ultimately, though, I'd say that the market performs the technocratic function far better than socialism ever could, and for that reason I may start advocating for the free market under the label market technocracy. My main reason is simply that the term "capitalism" comes with so terribly much baggage that using it often does more harm than good. I've thought about using other terms, but only liberalism seemed to fit, and that would only serve to confuse.

In addition, technocracy can be marketed with social reform towards a rational society. Capitalism is usually linked, both when it is and isn't warranted, to the various forms of conservatism, particularly social conservatism and traditionalism in general. I find many traditional ways of doing things (the English system of measurement, the Gregorian Calendar, contemporary public education) quite abhorrent for various reasons. Integrating reforms away from those into my political platform wouldn't be exactly distasteful.

Last thing tonight: would ordoliberalism be considered comparable to market technocracy?

05 April 2013

Integrated Approach

Most efforts to combat irrationality are unsystematic, incomplete, and one-sided. That is, they focus on one specific cause or effect of irrationality, usually the latter. They do not integrate that specific irrationality into a coherent framework. But most importantly, they attack from only one side, combating the cause without attacking the effect, or vice versa.

I propose to change that.

My idea is simple: chart out all the major effects of irrationality and the forces that contribute to existing irrationality. From this, determine the main factors that propagate irrationality and its effects. Then attack both the causes and effects of irrationality, in an integrated sweep.

02 April 2013

Some Sleep Addled Thoughts on the Culture War

I wasn't exactly self-aware when it was going on, but in retrospect, the "culture war" that the conservatives made some effort to wage in the early nineties was rather silly. A "culture war" requires separate subcultures (which there were) and separate cultural drivers (which there weren't). Essentially, the so-called culture war was, fundamentally, a political exercise, and did not accurately reflect on the subcultures of the United States.

Personally, I find the left- and right-wing "cultures" fairly irrational. Neither side really represents an integrated philosophy. The left advocates control over ones economic decisions, and freedom over ones body (except for a list a longer than the Appalachian Trail). The right claims to be all about economic freedom, but does love its cronyism, and is completely inconsistent about personal freedoms.

Really, I think the only "culture war" in this country, and in the whole of the western world, is reason versus feeling. The left and right both use different forms of feeling, and direct it at different things. But really they're the same.

Now there's probably someone out there who reads this an immediately thinks I'm some unemotional monster. You're funny. It's a typical argument: if you don't recognize the absolute supremacy of unintegrated feelings you're evil. That's insane. There's nothing wrong with rational emotions, that is, emotional states that do not conflict with reason. And it's exceedingly easy to live entirely with rational emotions. It just requires knowing oneself.

To return to my theme, though, we've got two cultures in America. There's the rational culture, focused on science, productivity, rational dialogue. That's the minority. The vast majority is the emotional culture, which doesn't worry about the sanity of what it's feeling. The feeling is more important than the cause of that feeling.

Emotionalism is impotent in the face of reality, but the emotionalists command such numbers they have political power. Wrestle politics away from them, and they'll be able to see the error of their ways soon enough.

That's the culture war in America.

24 February 2013

Updates

Nothing especially prominent coming to mind this evening, so I'll satisfy myself with making a general if incomplete report on what's been going on around me, with a bit of what's been going on in my head.

On second thought, that's not really what I want to say. Nothing going on around me is very interesting at the moment, but what I'm doing might be.

I'm thinking about taking on a big project, entirely outside of school. I probably don't have time for it, but I think it's well within my abilities to at least undertake part of it. Basically, I'm going to try to change the culture from the bottom up.

My thinking is this: people choose to be irrational because it's what they're raised with. Most people are smart enough to see the truth, but they've no experience with anything except the irrational. There are no dissenting voices. There's plenty of people working to combat the effects of an irrational culture, but little going into fixing the cause itself. My idea is to create an organization, a foundation (I hate to use such words, but my brain is a little out of sorts) that actively confronts irrationality throughout all of society, primarily trying to change the culture of irrationality. The working title is the The Rational Society.

We'll see how that works out. One of the means for that project would be a "Philosophy in Five Minutes" video blog on YouTube. I finally took 45 seconds to figure out the camera on my laptop (surprisingly easy, compared to 75% of the software you come across) and recorded myself talking for awhile. Given practice, I think I could pull off a series of short videos covering a variety of philosophical topics. I did a speech for AcaDec summarizing the whole of philosophy in four minutes, so covering a simple topic like the Law of Identity in five shouldn't be too much of a challenge.

In more mundane matters, school continues to be its usual bore. Running the marathon except we're doing in on a track in the stadium, and everyone else is either too dumb to notice or can't figure out why we're not getting anywhere. Hopefully, they're just not expressing the same thoughts as I, but I can't count on other minds. If I did, I'd spend all my days being disappointed.

The job search, or lack thereof. Putting in the applications, and hoping for the best. I'll most likely spend the summer doing something mundane, if I can secure a job at all, which, to be realistic, I probably won't. If that's the case, however, I'll work on something (such as the aforementioned) that I can still put on a resume.

Residence halls put on a rave Friday night. Probably a shoddy imitation of the real thing, not that I have any interest in either. Another one of those well-intentioned but halfhearted attempts to keep the kids from doing drugs and testing the contraceptive limits of latex. At most it kept a few of the meeker ones from passing out later, because the vast majority who would have partied still went out and partied afterwards. You can't just stop people from indulging their vices. I'll probably put up a post in a few weeks about why D.A.R.E. and similar programs don't work. Hint: the irrational culture (it's really a terribly convenient idea, I'll hate to abandon it when and if something better comes up).

My hair is a fright, strange as that is to type. I got it cut last around the 20th of December, and here we are nearly into March. I don't think it's been this long since that one time back in middle school, and I didn't shower last night to boot. Not to mention I never really stop having bedhead these days. Sleeping till noon anytime its permitted, regardless of bedtime, has that effect.

I think that's all for tonight. It's technically Monday now, but it's still a Sunday Night rant. All two bots out there enjoy!