Showing posts with label personal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label personal. Show all posts

13 October 2019

Last Sunday Night (for now)

I think it's time to admit that weekly reviews just aren't very compatible with my academics—a month is long enough to say that it's not a single occasion, but rather the general pattern of the semester.

I've been doing reasonably well (I still haven't gotten very many assignments back) and mostly maintaining my balance, but the process of slowing down long enough to reflect on the past week is a habit I've clearly broken. We're on Fall Break right now, which seems a reasonably enough time to state the matter openly.

Grad school is more reasonable than the demands of being an undergraduate upperclassman, but the fact remains that it isn't easy to maintain a writing habit. I started a couple of Fictober prompts, for instance, and almost instantly abandoned them simply because I had other assignments and such to worry about. Design reports seem to satisfy the itch well enough that I don't have to write—there's ideas still bouncing around in my head, both fiction and non, but fitting it into my schedule is....tricky.

In any case, this concludes a series of weekly reviews stretching almost a year. My conclusions is that they can help clear my mind to some extent, but do not in themselves provide too much in the way of self-organizational value. Talking about my life to friends on a regular basis probably goes further, with the added benefit of feedback or simple external insight. It's possible to get stuck going in circles, which is one of the reasons I'm so glad to have more friendships in my life than I remember having had right now.

Come to think of it, maybe that's why I don't feel so compelled to write about my personal life so often. It's gotten a lot less internal, and about that, I really can't complain.

02 June 2019

Twenty-Five

As of today, I have been an independently-breathing human being for a full quarter-century.

As recent birthdays have gone, this one has been pretty good. I woke up early, ate lunch with some friends, got a car wash, and went out for dinner with my parents. Last year there was a power outage and I accidentally ordered a spinach quiche at dinner. The year before that I could barely walk because I spent the day before crouching down constantly to show Cub Scouts how to launch model rockets.

We'll see how the coming year goes; the last year has felt largely like a zero on the sum of my life. At the same time, I feel a lot more mature than I did a year ago—but that's true every year. I think that's how growth works. The experiential and developmental aspects of maturation (which are...all of it, oui?) take time to occur.

A higher gain might be nicer, though.

01 April 2019

Winter 2019 Quarterly Review

In January, I laid out some objectives for the first quarter of 2019. The first quarter is now complete, so let's look at whether I completed those objectives.

My objectives for the first quarter were divided into four (4) focus areas. Of these, I did quite poorly in one, and acceptably but not impressively in the other three.

The first area was applying for jobs and graduate school. I completed my graduate school application, though this took longer than I had really expected. (The trip to Texas in mid-February rather disrupted the process.) Preparing for the GRE was a significant factor there, but that too has been put behind me. Since completing that process, I've resumed near-daily job applications, which I hope to keep up into the second quarter.

The second area was my self-directed study, which I continued but largely failed to accelerate. I worked through a number of technical papers that had be cluttering my desktop, which is a relief. I did not, however, finish reading Rocket Propulsion Elements as I had hoped; about 150 pages still await me. My general reading schedule has picked up again since finishing First Man, and in the last week I found library resources available to me that will considerably improve the situation (see the last weekly review for Q1).

The third area was cleaning and organization, and here I have precious little success to report. I put a little time into this back in January, but since then have done almost nothing to sort and catalog my various physical possessions. This is looking like less of a priority as the odds of attending grad school increase, but I would still rather have everything in its place.

The final area was writing, where again I did alright but unimpressively. I managed to publish at least one proper blog post each month so far (including April already) but went little beyond this. I've also tried to write a little fiction again—I managed to outline a plot that didn't strain my own suspension of disbelief, but only wrote a few pages of the text itself. This is a rather recent development, mind you, so I may very well pick the project back up again in the coming days.

High-level take-aways from this quarter are oddly similar to last quarter: I need to allocate more time to achieving my goals. This is more possible than before, but still somewhat challenging.

I had some success experimenting with time-blocking, but this was largely exhausted on GRE preparations, so I should try that again to associate it with something more emotionally rewarding. Planning my day in advance lets me think about what I actually need to achieve (assuming everything goes well).

A related issue, which I noted last time, is over-extension. My Q1 Objectives had a narrower focus than the original set six months ago, but even so I felt underspecified in what I was actually supposed to be doing. Now, I've dealt with some lesser matters that won't be recurring should I chose to continue this experiment, but the general point stands: chose which goals actually matter and pursue those exclusively.

The final issue I've noticed is that my time horizon is too broad for meaningful planning even over a three month period. I may opt to start pursuing month-by-month objectives, either in stead of or in addition to this quarterly system.

08 January 2019

Objectives for Q1

Heading into 2019, I am continuing my experiment of setting up quarterly goals. Whether I succeeded at my Q4 goals depends on your interpretation, but the results thus far are insufficient to draw a clear conclusion. So here we are.

This time, I'm grouping my objectives into four (4) focus areas. Arguably, my actual goals are more ambitious this time; however, some of these activities are self-reinforcing. Others fall under the same heading, but represent different ways of achieving that objective.

For instance, applying to jobs and graduate school do not produce mutually compatible outcomes, but that's okay, because they're alternate ways of moving into the next phase of my professional life. That's the first objective area.

The second objective area is self-directed studying. Here, I will continue reading textbooks and working exercises (I'm about 40% of the way through Rocket Propulsion Elements). I've also been reading some technical papers and would like to resume programming in other languages besides MATLAB. If I'm making good progress, I might try to work on some sort of technical project (programming or otherwise), but that's a secondary or even tertiary goal.

The third objective area is organization. This sorta ties in with the previous two, because a lot of my academic materials didn't come back from undergrad in the most orderly manner, and because if I move out, I'd like it to be a smoother transition. Even if not, cleaning up the house benefits the whole family and is long overdue.

The final objective area is writing. The main sub-objective is finishing my monthly blog posts in a more timely manner. This is achievable simply by allocating time regularly, as I found during NaNoWriMo. (This insight informs all of my objectives for the 1st Quarter.) Ideally, I'll begin posting more frequently than once or twice per month, but we'll just have to wait and see whether that happens.

I would also like to work on fictional projects again, though I've had some serious writer's block since the first week of December. If I allocate time to writing and revision, that may or may not clear up; I haven't really been in this situation before. There's also some ideas for long-form nonfiction stirring around in my head, but making a commitment would be premature at this time.

The same goes of any other major projects I could throw out, so I'll refrain from making unwarrented hypotheses. I would say that my objectives for Q1 look more like laying foundations and doing preparatory work rather than trying to achieve any particular goal. The results for particular goals were mixed in Q4. Perhaps this strategy will perform better.

Weekly reviews of my progress will be continuing each Sunday (unless something dramatic happens, in which case: no promises).

02 January 2019

Fall 2018 Quarterly Review

Back in October, I laid out some focus areas and strategies for the final months of 2018. I intend to do this again for the first quarter of 2019, but before that, it's worth taking the time to reflect on how well I did at meeting my Q4 objectives.

I had major objectives in nine (9) different areas. Of these, I achieved three, did not succeed at two, and made progress on four. Let's look at each of them in turn while considering how the different focus areas interacted with one another.

The most obvious success was selling our old house. That took a long time, a lot longer than anyone really expected—my facetious prediction of 2019 from last January very nearly turned out to be correct. It was correct, if you're limited to two sigfigs. Because this took almost the entirety of the quarter, some of the projects I might have had time to undertake if we had finished earlier went undone.

The other successes are somewhat less dramatic: competing in (and winning) NaNoWriMo and finishing Introduction to Flight. Neither of those went particularly impressively, but I managed to complete them while working on the house and dealing with other aspects of family life.

One aspect of family life that none of us managed very well was organization. I was specifically hoping to organize some of my possessions in advance of the possibility of moving out. (I had wanted to do this at the old house before Mom and Dad decided to move, but they sprung the announcement on me before any significant progress could be made.) I will probably be able to fold my own organization into the process of getting things set up in the new house, however.

Similarly, I did not make any real progress on the possibility of applying for graduate school, because we couldn't really afford it. We'll see about that this quarter, depending on how my continued job search goes.

Speaking of which: I made some continued progress in the hiring process in the fourth quarter, but did not secure employment. (I'm still waiting to hear back on the results of some of my phone interviews.) I don't feel that I submitted the sorts of quality applications I had been hoping to when I set aside Mondays—later switched to Tuesdays—for that specific purpose.

The same goes for my other nonfiction reading goals, and programming. I did well on the latter during October, culminating in an extensive blog post. Since then, however, I've barely touched MATLAB at all, let alone working in other environments. For the former, meanwhile, I managed to work through a few papers and presentations, but still have a lot of material waiting on my desktop.

In both cases, I see this as a failure to allocate time to goals. The problem, of course, was not that the goals were unimportant, but simply that there wasn't time for everything and they fell by the wayside. The lesson here is paring down one's objectives to what's reasonable with the time or resources at hand. This applies equally to the final focus area, nonfiction writing, where I managed to continue pushing out monthly blog posts, but didn't get very far with anything more expansive or frequent.

The high level lesson here remains more-or-less the same as always: set reasonable goals based on your true values while accounting for planning fallacy. I did moderately well last quarter, but could have done a lot better. I will be taking this into account in the coming months and trying to set my Q1 objectives with that in mind.

01 December 2018

NaNoWriMo Takeaways 2018

I won NaNoWriMo this year. I've never done that before.

Truth be told, I've never even come close. In 2013, I started planning a story but didn't commit any words to the page before turning my spare attention back to school work. In 2015, I got about about 13% of the way towards a reduced goal before losing focus. Since then, I've had to much on my plate to even naively think that I could complete.

Having now made the time commitment to write 50,000 words in the course of a month, I can say that I was right to wait. It's possible to accomplish a lot in the course of a month with a few hours every day, but during undergrad I certainly didn't have that many extra hours to spare. As a graduate, though, the equation in a little different.

My novel is nowhere near finished, but it's satisfying to have gotten so far into a fiction-writing project. As it turns out, my past attempts have been suffering, at least in part, from analysis-paralysis. My desire to plan out the story in intricate detail interferes with my ability to just sit down and put words on the page. Niven's 17th Law.

From here on out, my plan is to write about a thousand words per day, without worrying about it if I happen to fall behind one day. If I can keep that up, I'll be at 80,000 words by the end of the year. Whether the book will be done at that point is an entirely separate question. Once it is, I can start revising the draft in the direction of something publishable. I don't know if I'd ever want to publish this, but that's a matter for another day.

01 October 2018

Objectives for Q4

As we head into the last three months of 2018, I want to lay out my broad-strokes goals to concentrate upon for the remainder of the year. These aren't targets to hit, exactly, so much as areas in which to focus my efforts.

This is partially motivated by the fact that my output during the third quarter, despite being better than the first part of the summer, still leaves me feeling unsatisfied. Generally speaking, I've found over the years that living with my parents seriously impedes my productivity. There are a lot of potential explanations for this, which I've explored before at-length. We won't be rehashing those in detail today; suffice to say that certain individuals in my family wouldn't recognize priorities if an ordered list knocked on the front door. It seems that I'm constantly pulled between contradicting goals, with insufficient time to manage any of them adequately.

I suspect, however, that a big part of the problem is switching costs. These are really easy to underestimate if one isn't used to thinking in those terms, but are almost always non-trivial. My new strategy in Q4 is to break down my days of the week by objective, and, hopefully, focus on those objectives each day. This is, to some extent, a self-signalling strategy. By committing a certain amount of time to each major activity area, the emotional parts of my brain will better trust me to work on the various projects that it wants to see completed.

Note, however, that this takes some time to go into effect. I'll probably have to put my foot down on some of these issues, because, again, I'm the only person in this household not completely drowned in planning fallacy.

There are two major objectives for the rest of the year, both of which have some supporting objectives. The first is finding employment (or, alternatively, committing to grad school). The second is finishing the interminable project. Let's look at each of these, and their supporting objectives, in turn.

The single biggest change I'm implementing are Application Mondays. From here on out, the primary goal for every Monday is working on job applications. I don't necessarily have to submit them on Monday, but I would like to make progress. I've held off on a number of openings because I felt the need to really concentrate on them, but no opportunity to do so has ever materialized. Instead of waiting for the improbable, I'm designating an entire weekday to the job search.

There are two weekdays set aside for personal tasks and household chores, during which I may also work on applications. I do not expect to make much progress during the other four days of each week.

Supporting my efforts in that regard, I will be continuing and, hopefully, expanding my program of self-education. I've been reading John Anderson's Introduction to Flight to shore up my foundations in aerospace engineering, and to maintain something of my edge. Unfortunately, this has taken longer than expected. I would like to finish it before the end of the year, and move on to a more interesting book.

Studying engineering materials will remain on the agenda every day of the week, though it will remain a relatively small item (less than an hour each day). This does not mean just reading textbooks, but also working though the maze of technical papers that I've accumulated on my desktop. Several of these are several hundred pages long, so getting them read and filed away before the end of the year may be a real feat.

I would also like to practice my programming skills again, as well as expanding into a few new languages. That is a secondary objective, however.

The other major change which I am instituting is again a matter of compartmentalization. I am reducing the number of days each week which I'm spending on the house. By planning around this fact, however, I hope to dedicate more hours in total to the project. I will be spending two weekdays on whatever tasks I can complete individually. Weekends, if the past several months are any indicator, will be spent on tasks requiring two or more individuals.

This should enable us to finish the project in relatively short order. I'm hoping that the house will be on the market by the end of the month.

Indeed, I would like to have things finished well in advance of November, because I'd really like to participate in NaNoWriMo this year. I have some ideas which would be interesting to attempt, but I need a larger segment of unstructured time than is currently available for that to be practical. I will decide on a particular option closer to November 1 if participation is looking viable.

There are also a number of blog posts I've been meaning to write for some time. My hope is that this new schedule will also better serve my ambitions in that department. I don't think my prediction of two posts per month will end up being accurate, but I can probably manage four or five before the end of the year.

My final motivating for finishing the move in short order is that, should employment not be forthcoming, I need to start the process of applying to graduate school. That will require a good deal more money, which will not be available until the house is sold. I would like to have had that process started by mid-November if nothing turns up in the meantime.

I will attempt to keep the hypothetical reader apprised of my progress along these objectives.

24 December 2017

Going Off On A Tangent

I just remembered an incident from middle school. As a middle school memory, it's unremarkable in that it shouldn't have happened in the first place, but is unusual in that some small bit of wisdom can be gleaned from it.

Back then I was what passed for a gifted child, and consequently enrolled in what passed for a gifted education class. During one of my projects—I don't remember which one—one of the teachers said something to the effect that it seemed like I was going off on a tangent. I didn't know what a tangent was, so I tried to explain myself using the entirely incorrect geometric metaphor. Something about legs of a triangle. That's what you get for teaching algebra before trig before calculus.

With the benefit of hindsight, I can explain myself better.

Whatever line of research I was trying to pursue only looked like a tangent because outside observers weren't looking at the whole picture. My plans were outrageously overambitious as a rule; teaching a preteen the concept of planning fallacy isn't necessarily easy. Nevertheless, I can't shake the feeling that observing the size of the plan is not the hard part of that task.

If we're going to make it through the 21st century, we've got to fix a lot of different forms of irrationality. Giving our "best" and "brightest" such shoddy training does not bode well. 

02 December 2017

Hyperbolic Discounting Revisited

Related Reading: Picoprocrastination, Hyperbolic Discounting in Education

My, what a difference a year makes! As the months till graduation tick down, my time horizon has seemed to grow. It's not clear whether that's a product of the hard limit of my knowledge approaching, or my lived experience increasing.

Either way, my dissatisfaction with past selves has risen dramatically as 2017 progressed. At this point, I can even admit that my behavior—while not necessarily unpredictable given those initial conditions—was the primary reason I failed so dramatically during my years at Purdue. Four years doesn't seem like a particularly long time, not nearly as long as it felt five years ago, during my first semester of university.

Motivating myself with the prospect of being done with it (no, not like that) is now a viable strategy. It never worked before, and I found those kinds of pep talks somewhere between frustrating and completely incomprehensible. When I wrote about hyperbolic discounting in education, I was just barely starting to react to that line of reasoning, after a semester of struggling to make myself work through a workload that, in retrospect, was pretty good. I probably wouldn't have believed it then, but I'm actually nostalgic for Dr. D's thermodynamics class. It's unclear, however, how much of that perception stems from the broader situation.

Noticing progress can be a subtle art, but pleasurable nonetheless.

25 August 2016

Diary


I finished writing my diary last night. By which I mean it's filled, one end to the other.

I've been writing in it since Pi Day, 2002. I was seven at the time; now I'm 22. That's a full 65% of my life with this as my diary. During most of that time I wrote inconstantly and erratically, but it was always a thing I had around. Finishing it feels...weird.

Another journal was purchased long ago, so I won't be stopping entirely. In recent years I've also used various social media platforms and blogging sites to record my life, including this one. Nevertheless, I've found that private writing is more conducive to introspection than anything else, so for the time being that's not going anywhere.

20 June 2016

Missed my Sunday night post yesterday, on account of spending the weekend at home. My productivity has taken a huge hit, not the mention the easy points lost on the Fluid Mechanics exam today.

I would go into detail about the reasons spending time with my parents is detrimental to my grades, but they don't read this blog, which is actually kinda ironic considering that they're on the pro- side when it comes to parental snooping. Talk about not picking the low-hanging fruit.

Then again, my posting is so inconsistent maybe Mom just forgets about this blog for long periods at a time. Dad doesn't have a whole lot of time to look. It depends on how you choose to structure your free time. We have some substantial differences, but it won't profit me to get into them here.

Suffice to say that I'm not feeling up to the continuous stream of homework, which doesn't take a break just because I made a questionable decision. My plan is to turn in early and hope that when I wake up tomorrow I'm feeling less .... is there a word for this sensation? Probably. It'd be nice to know it right now.

On the bright side, I think I'm going to begin my reread of Atlas Shrugged before turning in. I haven't read a significant portion since high school (if memory serves), so it'll be interesting to see how I react to it after the last few years.

I should start exercising again while I'm at it.

08 May 2016

Hyperbolic Discounting in Education

We all instinctively assign a lower weight to a reward further in the future than one close at hand; this is "discounting the future". We don't just account for a slightly lower probability of recieving a more distant award, we value it at inherently less for being further away. It's been an active debate on overcomingbias.com whether such discounting can be rational at all. However, even if we allow that discounting can be rational, the way that we and other animals do it has a structure which is inherently irrational: the weighting we give to a future event is, roughly, inversely proportional to how far away it is. This is hyperbolic discounting, and it is an empirically very well confirmed result.
I say "inherently irrational" because it is inconsistent over time: the relative cost of a day's wait is considered differently whether that day's wait is near or far. Looking at a day a month from now, I'd sooner feel awake and alive in the morning than stay up all night reading comments on lesswrong.com. But when that evening comes, it's likely my preferences will reverse; the distance to the morning will be relatively greater, and so my happiness then will be discounted more strongly compared to my present enjoyment, and another groggy morning will await me. To my horror, my future self has different interests to my present self.
Compare to a college student's tendency to procrastinate, rush assignments, not study, and consequently get lower grades than they would otherwise. I'm looking at you, 2013!Nathaniel.
Actually, I still have this problem (though to a much lesser extent), which is why I'm writing this post when I have two final exams in the next 48 hours. While I dislike the university alarmism, the grades (and more importantly, habits) one obtains during their tertiary education has a tremendous impact on the trajectory of their life. Yet extremely little attention is given to the innate psychology of human beings which makes us act against our own long-term interests.
I'm not sure how to solve it, beyond increased self-vigilance while inculcating better behaviors. I've done better this semester (my first proper engineering courseload since 2014) and my grades, though far from ideal, are passable. I study a lot more than I did at Purdue and don't procrastinate as much. But there's been quite a few trivial inconveniences and general willpowers sinks that I'm hoping to avoid in the future (and would have already, if contract hadn't required me to endure them through May).

26 August 2015

Back to School--ish

It's a new school year! Except, well, I haven't had a term off since 2013. Summer classes have given way to something more closely resembling a proper academic load. Right now I'm signed up for Introduction to Aerospace Engineering, Computing for Engineers, Astrobiology and Russian Culture. Hopefully that'll hold, because I still haven't be formally admitted to the engineering school. I'm not buying textbooks till I find out.

Emotionally, I'm at a dead end. Getting to the fall semester was the extent of my thinking. Get through spring. Get through summer. Visit Mary in Minnesota. Start in the fall.

Now I need "goals" and "plans" again. For the time being, my plan is to go to class and stay on top of my schoolwork. I anticipate success: math and hard science classes were an academic drag, hoovering up far more time than they warranted. Now that I'm done on both counts, we can focus on what matters: spacecraft.

We're not doing that yet, but I've got Kerbal Space Program to sate me during these lower-level classes. We are building a drone this semester, which is more than Purdue can say.

Beyond that...I'm not sure. My professor for Intro to Aerospace was quite clear that he didn't believe engineering students have free time, period. Whether that's accurate is anyone's guess--but it's probably more accurate than not. All too many students come to college expecting it to be all fun and games, when really it's stress and all-nighters.

Was there really a time when I thought getting in would be the most ruthless part?

13 April 2015

On a Personal Note

I'm less than six weeks from finishing this semester at community college, and less than two months from returning to a conventional university. Unfortunately, my work and familial obligations are doing their best to keep me from devoting the proper effort to academics. Revealed preferences are fun.

All this has got me thinking  about conscious living, interpersonal relationships, and egoism, but conclusions are a long way off. There's a lot of other things I'd like to write about, but again, there's no time to ruminate on them properly. I'm in the process of setting up a less public blog where I can reflect on various small things without the pressure to state things completely.

For the time being, I'm not going to worry about it. If something comes up that can be written out quickly, it will be; otherwise, this blog will be in effective hiatus until June. Hopefully I can resume regular posting at that time.

09 March 2015

No More Politics?

For some time, I've been disinterested in your everyday object-level politics. However, I've taken a sort of hiatus from even metapolitics, and it's quite pleasant. It's quite possible I'm not going to go back.

There's several reasons why this is the case. For one thing, it's draining. You argue and explain and grind away, and it never seems like you're making any progress. In the end, you're faced with a dilemma: explain the 101 material for the umpteenth time, or veer into more advanced territory that's off-putting to newcomers. A Grunted and Hinged post on beginners and burning out described this process in detail. My experiences with libertarianism/Objectivism conform pretty well to the model.

Politics is also mind-killery. I don't think I need to walk anybody through this one. We've all felt it, that frenzy when your beliefs are being attacked. We instantly lose all ability to reason, fixating on discrediting our opponent's position, no matter how eloquently the argue or how much evidence they put forward.

That sensation is a product of our ape brains, still mostly optimized for life on the savanna. To my knowledge, there isn't a direct solution for this, but there are a few hacks to avoid being in that situation to begin with. The most popular tactic is keeping your identity small--or, if you prefer more colloquial terms, "being independent." Of course, Independent and Person-With-A-Small-Identity are still identities, and people will attack you for them.

(If you're thinking "I could be independent without making that part of my identity," I'm afraid it's too late. You also just lost the game.)

Furthermore, there's usually a reason someone starts identifying with a particular ideology or movement. You don't wake up one day saying "I think I'll be a feminist!" Going back to Gruntled and Hinged:

Let’s oversimplify a bit, and presume that the only question that feminism seeks to answer is whether or not women and men are equal.  So you, New Feminist, get involved in feminism (for the purposes of this exercise, and because I’ve already slightly oversimplified, please assume you’re female). You start identifying as a feminist, and as a result start having conversations/arguments/discussions about whether or not men and women are equal.
I emphasize this point, not to comment on feminism, but because your beliefs necessarily contribute to your identity, which then contributes to your behaviors.

Take my own example. I decided I valued natural rights, the Constitution, and limited government, and consequently began thinking of myself as a libertarian. Since I was a libertarian, I began discussing libertarian ideas. Wasted countless hours on the internet arguing about politics, and wasted my vote* on Gary Johnson.

But what did all that accomplish? I stressed over things I couldn't control and didn't shift the political landscape significantly. Meanwhile, my education (both formal and informal) languished. I paid the price for that, too--itself a reason to get out.

So now, I'm realigning my identity away from politics. My beliefs have shifted** and so have my priorities. How I label myself is important, because it's a way of caching the self. What political label you use will impact the direction your beliefs update. As a libertarian, I became more anarchistic and extreme, as a radical centrist the reverse occurred.

You should also try to replace the symbol with the substance. For a long time, I called myself a nerd, because it seemed like an accurate identifier. Even if we ignore the social connotations, though, it wasn't very useful. Nerd implies a lot of things to different people. For me, however, it referred to a relatively succinct set of interests in ideaspace. Now, I'll say "I'm interested in philosophy and spaceflight" instead of introducing myself as nerd. I still am one, but a very particular type of nerd.

The same goes in politics, but that's a lumper's game. Nuance dies upon first contact with the political. If you want to talk about complex ideas intelligently, getting out of politics is the way to go.

*I don't actually consider my vote wasted, since Romney was guaranteed to win Kansas. You could argue that voting at all was a waste of time (especially since I had to do the mail-in forms), but I was 18 and really wanted to.

**More on that later.

22 February 2015

Agnostic Lent

“Even now,” declares the Lord,
  “return to me with all your heart,
  with fasting and weeping and mourning.”
Rend your heart
  and not your garments.
--Joel 2:12-13
I am not a very religious person. This probably isn't much of a surprise to those who know me, but in case there was any doubt, there is it. Most of my spiritual life has been spent in the agnostic/deist/rationalist school of thought, thanks in no small part to my secular parents and a wide range of reading materials.

Since my grandmother died, however, Mom and Dad have started attending church again regularly. Naturally I've been towed along to a few services over the months, which for the most part haven't impressed me. Without the promise of eternal life, true altruism breaks down as a moral system.

(I may have to do a post on that sometime.)

So naturally, I wasn't expecting very much when we piled in the car for my first ever Ash Wednesday service. Lent, after all, is traditionally presented as a time of penance and self-denial. We give up something we like to grow closer to God (and each other). Not exactly an egoist nonbeliever's cup of tea.

But that wasn't the path our pastor took. Many people give things up for Lent, she said, things like junk food or alcohol or cigarettes. For the most part, they give up things they should be giving up anyway, because they're self-destroying. She asked us to abstract that into the intellectual sphere. She asked us to try--for 40 days--to give up self-destructive mindsets and behaviors, like blame, procrastination, and greed.

I disagreed on some of her particulars (thought it might've been a case of the definitions), I still think that's a very good message. Lent makes a good Schelling point for changing one's behavior. So does the New Year--yes, making resolutions does have value, if you know what you're doing, and are willing to stick with it.

I'm not giving up anything in particular this Lent, in part because I need to figure out what behaviors to modify. Thanks to our pastor, though, I have a better notion of how to approach this.

Oh, and I got one of those dorky ash crosses:


31 January 2015

Failure in the New Year

We're a month into the New Year, and I'm already falling down on my resolutions. Not that I had anything formal, but I was hoping to finally meet my one-post-per-week goal and start flossing regularly. I have been successful at brushing my teeth left-handed.

It's interesting: I had a giant post planned about How to Make 2015 better. It won't be published, though its content will probably slip out elsewhere. I missed a major point, though: conceptualization. I'll be doing a proper post on it soon (maybe), but the problem we have is that we don't adequately conceive, plan, and execute our goals.

Resolutions fail because we use them to wrap up self-improvement in glittering generalities. Success requires concrete percepts and a clear vision forward, covering all the necessary points. That's hard, so most people don't bother. Who cares about making progress when you can feel good?

I do.

29 December 2014

New Year's Resolutions Followup 2014

I didn't do the best job of keeping my New Year's Resolutions. 

I did a fairly good job flossing the first half of the year, and fell apart after that. I didn't come close to posting weekly, though I averaged around one every 10 days. When you consider the gaps, however...

And the periodic calendar--I never used it to any degree worth mentioning. Instead, it offers a clear example of why these Resolutions often fail: no true change in behavior or environment to facilitate them. It wouldn't have been difficult to bookmark an adequately large image or save it to my desktop. Then, I could have consulted it easily. As it was, my poster was hung in a very inaccessible corner of my dorm.

My resolutions for 2015 are yet to be determined, but once I've chosen, these are things to keep in mind.

22 December 2014

Obligatory December Post

I want to meet my goal of making three more posts before the year ends, but I've got nothing. Which is to say, I've got 15 drafts but not the willpower to finish any of them. Instead, I'm going to ramble a bit and you're free to ignore me.

Part of my problem is that I've got all these grandiose notions and no good way to implement them. Take, for instance, my forthcoming post on the Single Transferable Vote. I'd be just thrilled if every state of the union adopted it tomorrow, but that's not going to happen. No one with the power to do it, has the incentive. Indeed, many of them have a strong incentive against it. Minor parties love the idea, but Republicans and Democrats--not so much. How do we convince them to put it in place? I haven't the foggiest.

It's a great deal like issues of drug legalization. Despite widespread support, it moves along at a snail's pace. Part of that can be blamed on the federal government, which will pull highway funding and continue to conduct drug raids to confiscate legal substances. To end the drug war, we have to challenge the existing laws and regulations made in Washington.

That's basically impossible because a plurality, if not majority, of Congressmen will be voted out of office for seeming "soft on drugs." Even if they know a policy will be good for the country in the long term, their constituents don't know (or worse, don't care).

This is, incidentally, the reason that nobody ever cuts spending without a showdown. "We saved the country from a government shutdown!" goes over better than "We agreed to raise your taxes and cut your benefits," even if the latter is a smarter plan.

Scott Alexander calls this Moloch, the demon of perverse incentives. It basically rules our society, and there's no easy way to combat it.

There's a few things you can do, of course. First of all, extend your time horizon. If I ever run for a legislative office, I'm not going to plan on reelection. Unless the polls are in my favor, I won't even run for a consecutive term. I would rather do a good job, that people remember later, than gain their benefit at the time.

To put it another way: statesman should not be a career.

Another thing is to donate to charity. Yes, an Objectivist is telling you to be altruistic. But I do it a somewhat unconventional way. There's a browser extension for Firefox and Chrome called Tab For a Cause, which displays a few ads every time you open a new tab. Proceeds are directed towards reputable charities like Human Rights Watch, Water.org, and Conservation International.

Individual tabs aren't worth much, but they add up. Since I started in mid-September, my tabbing alone has raised about $7.30--or enough to give a year of clean water to six people in the developing world. This is without any significant time, money, or behavior change on my part.

(Also, if you follow the specific link there, I get more tabber points, called "hearts," which I'll be donating to Educate!)

Probably the most important thing you can do, though, is the recognize your own strengths and weakness (then improve on both). As much as it pains me to admit, one person can't make society rational, peaceful, and prosperous. However, you can increase your own rationality and productivity, and help those around you do the same.

26 November 2014

The Marble Sorter

Outdated logo? Yes.
My shortlist of Things I am Still Not Over reads something like this:
  1. All the arguments I've ever lost
  2. The 2012 Republican Presidential Primary
  3. The Marble Sorter
For those blessedly unaware, the marble sorter is an assignment in the Project Lead The Way pre-engineering program. Small teams of students are tasked with designing, building, and testing a system to sort marbles based on color. The project format has changed a number of times, including the materials (we used fischertechniks, I believe Vex is now standard), plus the many tweaks teachers make to fit their resources. But that's inconsequential.

What matters is how badly my partner and I failed, and why.

In the end, we never did get a decent performance. The criteria specified that all the marbles would be dropped into the machine at once, and then sorted by color into three categories. (Marbles came in blue, black, and clear. Extra credit was available if it could distinguish between dark blue and black marbles.) In the end, ours could distinguish between clear and opaque marbles, under the right conditions, if they were loaded one by one. On a project worth a huge percentage of the semester grade, we got around fifty percent.

And we had to fight for that. We came in early, and stayed late. Principles of Engineering was right before lunch, and I missed a few meals for that project. It inhabited my dreams (I know, I was keeping a journal for Psychology). I fantasized about tearing it apart and starting afresh, and over four years later I'm still thinking about it.

But that wouldn't have made a difference, because Nathan and I weren't using good engineering practice.

There's a programming proverb: "resist the urge to code." In engineering, this applies to both the software and the hardware. It strikes me as odd the Principles of Engineering curriculum didn't mention it. Maybe it did and the lesson just didn't stick. Regardless, we ignored any cautionary impulse, and began building with only an excuse for a plan. We drop the marbles into a hopper, they roll down a chute, a door lets one out, the photosensor tells us its color, put the bins on a track that moves back and forth, and another door opens to drop the marble into the appropriate bin. What could go wrong?

Quite a lot, it turns out.

I could go into many, many details, but (fortunately for you, readers) I've forgotten most of them. I still have my notebooks lying around somewhere, but our slack documentation would have gotten us fired from any worthwhile company. This itself was another bad practice, which hamstrung our ability to replicate more successful approaches and identify what wasn't working.

One of those things was our approach to the materials. I'd experienced fischertechniks in middle school at a PTLW-sponsored summer program, and really should have understood just how stubborn they are. Yet we blundered ahead as if they were modelling clay, and burnt through huge chunks of our limited time trying to make them bend to our will.

A particular instance that sticks out in my memory: the mess we made trying to build and secure one of the doors. What's worse, though, was trying to reconstruct it after taking it apart. In retrospect, the situation was ridiculous. The whole system was elevated for no good reason. We had to build ridiculous struts and cantilevers, when we could have just attached the motor cleanly if we'd had the sense to set the system on a lower platform.

Unnecessary elevation brings us to our next point: ignoring basic scientific principles.

For a system driven largely by gravity, you would think doing some physics would occur to us. Then again, I'd only had the briefest introduction.

In the final days of the project (when we'd already missed the deadline and were fighting for completion points) we had several recurring frustrations. First, our chute, hopper, and bin systems didn't work very well at containing the marbles. They had an annoying tendency to bounce right out of the marble sorter altogether. The reason for this was very simple: elevating the system gave the marbles too much potential energy.

Potential energy was also the root cause of our second problem. No matter how much time we spent tweaking, we never could figure out the precise time the doors needed to open and close. We'd run several tests with an individual marble, then find all our measurements useless when we dumped the whole load in.

We had some clue at the time that it was the marbles' collective weight pushing on the marble, which usually resulted in two or three getting through. With my current knowledge of physics, I realize it's an application of weight and Newton's Third Law.

Weight  = mass * gravitational acceleration
Force = mass * acceleration

In the first equation, mass refers to that of the marbles altogether. In the second, it's the mass of an individual marble. Stated symbolically:

mload * accelgrav = massmarble * accelmarble

For the non-STEM people out there, this means the accelerationspeed a marble goes through the gate is related to the number that have already gone through. Later marbles go through slower than earlier ones.

We spent hours trying to find the right gate time, instead of taking a more sophisticated approach--either varying the gate time, or redesigning the hopper and chute to eliminate the gravitational effect.

Our final problem was more technical than scientific, because we knew the principle at play here. How do you measure slight differences in pigment when the ambient light is so variable? The obvious answer is to fully enclose, to the greatest degree possible, the area where pigment measurements are taken. We did this, but only with considerable reluctance and didn't do a very good job of it, because we still had some trouble.

The already flawed design, which we waited too late to modify, had a lot to do with it. We didn't know about sunk costs--yet another reason engineers need to learn economics. We had this problem in the first place, because we didn't consider external factors in developing our design.

At the time, the marble sorter almost drove me to a mental breakdown. Failure after failure had me seriously doubting the validity of reason (the unstated assumption was that I was operating rationally). I think it should now be clear this was not the case. After five years, the lessons are sinking in, and I'm finally get some closure. If only the other two items on the list were so easy.